ICE & Immigrant Detention Reform

As the Obama Administration enters its second year, and as comprehensive immigration reform struggles to remain a viable policy initiative for 2010, Assistant Secretary for the Department of Homeland Security and head of ICE, John Morton spoke recently at the Migration Policy Institute in Washington DC.

In his remarks, Morton emphasized his commitment to reform immigrant detention, which remains a laudable if overdue goal. The Administration has been advocating detention reform for most of 2009 (in August and October) and most of its initiatives remain unimplemented.  According to Morton, ICE detains about 32,000 immigrants on any given day. Immigrants are held in a vast network of over 300 most penal detention facilities (private, county, state and federal) around the country.

This is the nut of the problem: the federal government has lost control over an immigrant detention system that incarcerates a father of five whose visa expired along with a violent felon who happens to be an immigrant. Violent criminals sit alongside nonviolent offenders, and felons sit along side persons who merely violated civil (administrative) law provisions.

In violation of its own bail standards, ICE continues to detain immigrants whose record shows they are neither a flight risk nor a risk to their community. These immigrants should not be detained.

Thousands of detained immigrants should not be detained, and thousands more who are detained are being held under abusive conditions that imperil their safety and violate due process in conditions that are cruel and unusual.

A big part of the problem has to due with private prisons and the neo-liberal logic that informs detention practices even in public facilities. The logic encourages detention of immigrants for the purpose of keeping beds filled, even for immigrants who pose no risk. The logic condones secrecy and discourages public accountability.

According to John Morton, ICE endeavors to change this logic; it has plans to render a more transparent and accountable detention system; it plans greater oversight and monitoring of private detention practices and more vigilant review of contracts. But, and this is a big but, Morton suggests no concrete effort to terminate contracts with private facilities nor turn away from this underlying action opriented system of ideas that has rendered the system so unaccountable and secretive.

In other words, as extensive as John Morton’s plans for reforming immigration detention sound, they remain glued to a logic that is bound to socially reproduce these same shortcomings down the road.

Immigrants deserve better.


2 responses to “ICE & Immigrant Detention Reform

  1. God's Sheppard


    Thank you for posting this info. I am desperate. My fiance has been in a county jail for two weeks now. He has been in US since 84 and in 2001 was caught in the middle of a “petty theft” .. he now has 2 strikes of “petty theft” AKA moral trupitude which I know know is a BIG NO NO!!! He is a working man, we have a 4 year old daughter with a rare development condition, he owns his house and was detained on 32/19/10 because he was trying to do the right things and apply for US citizenship so that he can vote and make USA a better place. We are Chrisitains, tithe weekly and are involved in Church. I don’t know why they are holding him in a jail with phones so horrible we can’t even talk cause the lines are so bad! We have a lawyer that Im nto too happy with and think his interest is in collecting money from me. I feel as if we can be pushing for a bond a little harder. I am in risk of loosing my job now because I am having to take kids to school/pick them up/ take her to therapy etc… We will loose the house, cars, and soon all of our money! Please Please Please help if anyone thinks I can take this a little further and possibly LORD WILLING get him bond so that he can at least work and be home with the family while was pray for the best outcome possible. IF we need to move out of the US we will but until that decision is made I NEED HIM HOME not for just the physical support but for my daughter who is suffering with her development because “daddy” is not home and is causing her to take steps backwards in her development. He is not a threat to the community and is a good citizen who like many others in their past made a mistake but asked for forgiveness and grew up and became a positive and person of good moral.

  2. God's Sheppard

    I’m willing to speak out and step up! Its not fair.. give him community service.. I’ll do it with him!! Just let these detainees go, those who are not a threat…. I will continue to pray and let GOD control out next move.. but until then, if anyone can give me my “breath” back I’d greatly appreciate and listen to any feedback given. May God Bless you all!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s